You drive through Sumter County. You need a solid meal. Livingston offers few spots. Diamond Jim’s and Mrs. Donna’s tops the list. It draws travelers off I-20/59. You get steaks and seafood here. Ratings hit 4.2 from 98 reviews. This guide covers details. You plan your stop.
Diamond Jim’s Leads the Pack
Diamond Jim’s and Mrs. Donna’s sits at 440 Highway 28 W, Livingston, AL 35470. Family owns it. They hand-cut steaks daily. Special marinade. Charcoal grill. Fresh seafood in homemade batter. Bar-b-que pork works too.
You call ahead at (205) 652-5750. Takeout available. Wheelchair access. Price runs mid-range, $$ to $$$. Reviews rank it number one or two of 12 spots in town. People praise the food. Small town means consistent quality.
Livingston’s dining scene stays limited. No big chains dominate. This place fills the gap for travelers. You exit the highway. You eat hearty. You continue your Alabama road trip.
Hours and Access Details
Check hours before you go. They close Mondays and Tuesdays. Open select times rest of week.
| Day | Hours |
|---|---|
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 4:30 PM – 9:00 PM |
| Thursday | 11:00 AM – 1:30 PM, 4:30 PM – 9:00 PM |
| Friday | 11:00 AM – 1:30 PM, 4:30 PM – 9:00 PM |
| Saturday | 4:30 PM – 9:00 PM |
Table shows lunch on Thursday and Friday. Dinner most evenings. You arrive early for lunch. You avoid waits. Spot parks easy off Highway 28. Five minutes from interstate.
Menu Highlights
Order hand-cut ribeye. Charcoal marks show. Medium rare stays juicy. Pair with twice-baked potatoes. Side salad balances it. Seafood comes battered fresh. Bar-b-que pork suits lighter appetites.
No full menu online lists prices. Check Diamond Jim’s menu and reviews on Restaurant Guru for updates. Portions satisfy. American steakhouse style fits road trips.
You book nearby hotels after. Germ Trips lists cheap stays in Sumter County. You refuel here. You head to Tuscaloosa or Meridian.
Other Dining Options
Dog Street Cafe and Outfitters runs second. Address at 309 Monroe St, Livingston, AL 35470. American cafe fare. Burgers. Patty melts. Loaded fries. Breakfast on Saturdays. Craft beer selection.
Hours run Tue-Fri 10:00 AM to 8:00 PM. Saturday 9:00 AM to 8:00 PM. Closed Sunday-Monday. Ratings average 4.3 to 4.4. Travelers note friendly staff. Quaint atmosphere. Historical photos on walls.
You walk in for casual. Phone (205) 575-4506. Check Dog Street Cafe menu on Restaurant Guru. Smoothie King offers quick healthy drinks. Limited fast food rounds out choices.
Tips for Your Livingston Stop
You fly into Birmingham or Meridian. Drive 90 minutes tops. Rent a car. Gas up before rural stretches. Book hotels in Livingston or nearby Eutaw. Cheap options start under $80 nightly.
Pair dining with University of West Alabama events. Football games draw crowds. Call restaurants direct. Confirm hours. Cash works best in small towns. You tip well. You support locals.
No recent 2026 updates shift rankings. Reviews hold steady. You read Foursquare tips for Dog Street Cafe. Small scene means you pick based on craving. Steaks win for most.
Final Takeaways
Diamond Jim’s delivers the best restaurant experience in Livingston, Alabama. You get reliable steaks and service. Limited options keep it simple. Check hours. Call ahead.
You plan your trip around this stop. Road food beats chains. Safe travels through Sumter County.
