Coney Island Hotels: Where to Stay in New York

Hotels in Coney Island are few. The neighborhood sits at the southern tip of Brooklyn, home to the boardwalk, Luna Park, and the New York Aquarium, yet only a small group of hotels stand close by. This guide lists the Coney Island hotels we could confirm with at least two sources, flags every gap, and explains how to choose a base. The old version of this page named several hotels we could not find anywhere. We removed them. Rates change daily, so we quote none. Confirm every detail with the property before you book.

Compare Coney Island, New York hotels on Expedia

Where to Stay in Coney Island, New York

Best Western Brooklyn-Coney Island Inn

This is the closest confirmed hotel to the amusement district. The Best Western site gives the address as 2632 West 13th Street, Brooklyn, NY 11223. The hotel page lists check-in at 3:00 PM and check-out at 11:00 AM.

The listed amenities include a free daily breakfast buffet, free Wi-Fi, and free on-site parking. Rooms have air conditioning, a refrigerator, a desk, and a coffee maker. The hotel also lists a 24-hour front desk, a business center, and a fitness center. The page says the hotel has no pool.

Best Western lists the boardwalk, beach, and Luna Park at roughly 0.75 to 1.2 miles. Booking.com shows 0.7 miles from Coney Island. The Bay 50th Street subway station on the D line sits about 0.3 miles away, according to the Best Western page. Treat all distances as approximate and check a map before you book.

One detail stays unclear. The FAQ on the Best Western page says pets are not accepted, but the amenity tags say pet friendly. Call the hotel if you travel with an animal. We did not find a direct hotel phone number, so use the booking page to reach the property.

Sleep Inn Coney Island

Sleep Inn Coney Island stands at 2586 Stillwell Avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11223. Both the Choice Hotels listing and a Sembo hotel profile confirm the address. Sembo describes a hotel with 53 air-conditioned rooms.

The listings show free Wi-Fi, a free breakfast, a 24-hour front desk, elevators, and an ATM. Sembo adds a refrigerator and microwave in the rooms, a coffee maker, an iron, and a hair dryer. Children 18 and under stay free in a parent room when they use existing bedding. Smoking and pets are not allowed.

Sources disagree on a few points. Choice Hotels lists a free hot breakfast, while other listings say continental breakfast. One listing says parking is free on site. Another says parking is limited and uncovered. Sembo puts the hotel about 1.2 miles from Coney Island Beach, while a third listing calls the boardwalk a short walk away. We could not find check-in or check-out times. Ask the front desk about breakfast, parking, and times before you arrive.

Best Western Plus Brooklyn Bay Hotel in Sheepshead Bay

This hotel sits a bit farther from the rides. The address is 3003 Emmons Avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11235, and the phone number is 718-769-5000. Check-in starts at 2:00 PM and check-out ends at 11:00 AM.

The hotel lists 48 loft-style rooms and a complimentary full breakfast served daily from 7:00 to 10:00 AM. Guests get free Wi-Fi, a 24-hour fitness center, and a 24-hour front desk. Outdoor parking is free but limited and first come, first served. The building has a wheelchair-accessible elevator and is smoke free.

The Best Western page puts the Sheepshead Bay piers about 0.3 miles away. The same page lists Coney Island Beach at about 1.5 miles and the New York Aquarium at about 2.1 miles. Booking.com shows slightly longer distances. Pick this hotel if you want a waterfront area with restaurants and a quieter evening, and accept a longer trip to the boardwalk.

Hotels in Coney Island Near Luna Park and the Boardwalk

Many travelers search for a hotel right on the boardwalk. We found no confirmed hotel there. The two closest confirmed options sit about a mile from the beach, and sources disagree on the exact distance. Plan for a short walk, a bus ride, or a quick subway hop.

Luna Park stands at 1000 Surf Avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11224. The park describes itself as home of the Cyclone and Thunderbolt roller coasters. Park hours vary by day and weather, so check the park calendar on the Luna Park website. The park lists a phone number of 718-373-5862.

Surf Avenue is the main street of the amusement district. If you want to see the rides at night, choose a hotel with a simple route to a subway station and check the last train time before you go out.

The Shore Theater and the Hotel Plans for Surf Avenue

The landmarked Shore Theater stands at 1301 Surf Avenue. In June 2018, the Brooklyn Eagle reported plans filed with the Department of Buildings to turn the building into a seven-story hotel. The developer, PYE Properties, called the project extremely preliminary at the time.

We found no source showing a finished hotel in the building or a booking page for one. Do not plan a stay there. If you see a hotel listed at this address, call to confirm before you pay anything.

Old Listings We Removed From This Guide

The earlier version of this page named a series of hotels. We searched for each one and found no listing in any source we checked. We removed The Brooklyn Mermaid, The Asbury Ocean Club, The Wheelhouse Hotel, The New York Aquarium Hotel, and The Wonder Wheel Motel. We also removed The Sea Isle Motel and The Hotel Tides, which the old page mentioned in passing.

Absence from a search does not prove a place never existed. A hotel might have closed or changed its name. Still, we will not send you to a property we cannot verify. If a site shows one of these names, call the number on the official site first and confirm the street address.

Hotels Near Coney Island Attractions

Most visitors come for a short list of places. Use this list to match a hotel to your plans.

Hotels Near the New York Aquarium

The New York Aquarium stands at 602 Surf Avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11224. The aquarium lists a Sunday schedule with opening at 10:00 AM and closing at 4:30 PM on the date we checked, with last entry at 3:30 PM. Hours change by season and date, so open the aquarium schedule page before you go.

The aquarium directions say to take the F or Q train to West 8th Street, or the N or D train to Coney Island-Stillwell Avenue and walk two blocks east on Surf Avenue. The aquarium also lists the B36 and B68 buses. We did not verify walking times from any hotel to these routes.

Where to Stay Near the Coney Island Museum

The Coney Island Museum stands at 1208 Surf Avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11224. The official site lists weekend hours of noon to 5:00 PM and notes the museum can close for special events. The museum is on the second floor and is not wheelchair accessible. Weekend walking tours start at 1:00 PM and run about 90 minutes.

The Coney Island Circus Sideshow has ended its 2026 season and returns in 2027, according to the same site. Confirm all hours before you travel, because the season and the hours shift through the year.

Getting to Coney Island by Subway and Bus

The Coney Island visitor page says to take the D, Q, N, or F train to Coney Island-Stillwell Avenue. The station is wheelchair accessible. The page also lists the B36, B64, B68, B74, and B82 buses. Check the MTA website for service changes before you travel, because weekend work can reroute trains.

Driving is possible, but we did not verify parking near the rides. If you drive, ask your hotel about parking and confirm the rules on the day you travel.

How to Choose Among Motels and Hotels in Coney Island

We found no confirmed motels in Coney Island itself, only chain hotels. Use these questions to choose.

Do you want the shortest trip to the rides? Start with the Best Western Brooklyn-Coney Island Inn and the Sleep Inn. Do you want a waterfront area with restaurants? Look at the Best Western Plus in Sheepshead Bay. Do you need breakfast? All three list a free breakfast, but the type differs, so confirm. Do you need parking? All three list some parking, but each has limits, so ask.

Booking.com and Trivago also list hotels in Dyker Heights, Marine Park, and Sunset Park. Their listed distances from Coney Island run from about 3.6 miles to over 5 miles. We checked these only on aggregator pages, so treat them as unconfirmed leads. Compare the distance and the train route before you choose one.

What We Checked and What We Could Not

We checked the Best Western Brooklyn-Coney Island Inn on the Best Western site and on Booking.com and Trivago. We checked the Sleep Inn Coney Island on Choice Hotels, Sembo, and a travel booking page. We checked the Best Western Plus Brooklyn Bay Hotel on a Best Western booking page and on Booking.com and Trivago. We checked the attractions on the Luna Park, New York Aquarium, and Coney Island sites.

We could not confirm current room rates, so we quote none. We could not confirm Sleep Inn check-in times or a direct phone number for the Best Western Coney Island Inn. We could not confirm pet rules at the Best Western Coney Island Inn. We could not verify walking times from any hotel to the rides. Call each property to confirm.

Frequently Asked Questions

Conclusion

Hotels in Coney Island are few, and we confirmed only three with reliable sources. The Best Western Brooklyn-Coney Island Inn and the Sleep Inn Coney Island sit closest to the rides, and the Best Western Plus Brooklyn Bay Hotel offers a waterfront base in Sheepshead Bay. Call ahead, confirm the details we flagged, and check attraction hours before you go.