East Hampton Hotels: Where to Stay in New York
Hotels in East Hampton, NY checked against two sources each. See The Maidstone, Mill House Inn, Baker House 1650 and Journey, with honest gaps flagged.
Looking for hotels in East Hampton, New York? The village has a small, high-end lodging list. Most places are inns and boutique hotels, not big chains. This guide covers every East Hampton hotel we could confirm with at least two independent sources. We flag the gaps too. Rates change daily and by season, so we quote none. Call each property before you book.
Compare East Hampton, New York hotels on Expedia
Compare places to stay in East Hampton, New York
Live prices and availability on Expedia, for the dates you choose.
Check hotel prices →Booking is handled by Expedia. We may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you.
Where to Stay in East Hampton, NY
Table of Contents
Hotels in East Hampton Village at a Glance
East Hampton is a village on the South Fork of Long Island. Main Street runs through the center. Most of the inns below sit on or near Main Street, so guests can walk to shops and restaurants.
We confirmed four lodging properties in or beside the village. Three sit in East Hampton itself: The Maidstone, Mill House Inn, and The Baker House 1650. Journey East Hampton sits just off Montauk Highway, on the road toward Amagansett. We also cover The Roundtree, which lies in nearby Amagansett.
Every property here is a small inn or boutique hotel. We found no budget motel in the village itself. Travelers on a tight budget should read the section on how to choose a hotel in East Hampton below.
The Maidstone: Boutique Hotel on Main Street
The Maidstone stands at 207 Main Street. Call 631-324-5006. Travel listings count 19 rooms. A hotel guide describes 16 rooms in the main house and three standalone cottages.
Expedia lists check-in from 3:00 PM to 11:00 PM and check-out at 11:00 AM. Late check-in is available during limited hours. Room types include Classic Queen, Classic King, Deluxe King, Premier Double King, junior suites, and several cottage rooms.
An on-site restaurant called LDV serves Italian-inspired food. A bar and lounge sit beside the dining room. Listings also mention free Wi-Fi, free self-parking, pet-friendly stays and continental breakfast. Some rooms have fireplaces or kitchenettes.
A lawn and patio sit in front of the white-shingled building. Hotel bikes are available, and one guide puts East Hampton Beach about five minutes away by bike. We found no pool listed. Guest reviews praise the staff and restaurant. A few reviewers mention noise and dated rooms. Confirm pet fees and parking details by phone.
Mill House Inn: Historic Inn Near Downtown
Mill House Inn sits at 31 North Main Street. Call 631-324-9766. An Oyster review says the building dates to 1790 and runs as a year-round bed-and-breakfast. Another listing says a 2008 renovation updated the rooms.
Sources disagree on room count. Oyster lists 10 rooms and suites. Expedia lists 11 room types, including a separate cottage called Graybarn Cottage. Ask the inn which rooms are open when you book.
Expedia lists check-in from 3:00 PM to 9:00 PM and check-out at 11:00 AM. The inn includes a cooked breakfast. Guests can eat in the dining room or the rose garden, and suites can order breakfast in the room. Free parking and Wi-Fi appear in listings. No pool is listed.
Oyster calls Mill House Inn a peaceful stay for quiet-seekers and notes the inn is not on the beach. The same review puts downtown about a five-minute walk away. Some rooms do not allow pets. Check the pet policy before you travel.
The Baker House 1650: Manor-Style Inn
The Baker House 1650 stands at 181 Main Street. Call 631-324-4081 or email info@bakerhouse1650.com. Indagare describes a 17th-century English manor-inspired inn open year-round. The inn’s own site confirms the address and phone.
Guests can book rooms in the Baker House or the Carriage House. Named rooms include The Hunting, The Lily Pond, The Gardiner and The Hedges. The Loft is a private suite with a fireplace and a walk-out terrace.
The inn offers spa treatments and a private dry sauna. Its site also mentions an aperitivo cocktail hour on Friday and Saturday evenings and a monthly afternoon tea on the first Sunday. A guest review mentions two pools, but we could not confirm this from the inn itself.
We could not find check-in or check-out times or a pet policy. Call the inn to confirm both. Indagare suggests the inn suits couples and travelers without children.
Journey East Hampton: Modern Hotel Off Montauk Highway
Journey East Hampton sits at 490 Pantigo Road, off Montauk Highway, between East Hampton and Amagansett. The property was once the Inn at East Hampton. 27 East reported the sale in July 2018, and the buyer rebranded the site as Journey East Hampton.
Mr and Mrs Smith lists 25 rooms, including 15 suites. Check-in is at 4:00 PM and check-out is at 11:00 AM. Both times are flexible when the hotel has space. A heated saltwater pool sits on a raised deck beside the garden. A lobby bar serves guests, and garden lawn games are on site.
Continental breakfast runs from 8:00 AM to 10:30 AM. The hotel has no restaurant and no room service. Wi-Fi and parking are free. The hotel has an accessible suite and lobby.
The older version of this guide placed the hotel on the beach with Atlantic balconies. We found no source for this claim. Treat Journey as a roadside hotel with a pool, not a beachfront resort. Ask the hotel how guests reach the ocean.
Nearby Option: The Roundtree in Amagansett
The Roundtree is not in East Hampton village. The address is 273 Main Street, Amagansett. We include the hotel because many travelers search for East Hampton and then look at Amagansett.
Mr and Mrs Smith and Small Luxury Hotels both list 14 rooms. Smith counts five cottages. Check-in is at 3:00 PM and check-out is at 11:00 AM. Listings mention a garden, a fire pit, borrowed bikes and beach gear, and free parking and Wi-Fi.
The hotel has no restaurant. Smith says the staff serve continental breakfast from 8:00 AM to 10:00 AM, plus afternoon tea. We found no pool listed. The old version of this guide called the hotel a 250-year-old working farm with a pool. We could not confirm either claim, so we dropped them.
East Hampton Motels and Budget Hotels
Many travelers search for a motel in East Hampton. Our research found none inside the village center. Every property above is a boutique inn or small hotel.
If you need a lower-cost stay, widen the search to nearby hamlets and towns along Montauk Highway. Use the Expedia link at the top of this page to compare current options. Always read recent reviews and confirm the location on a map. We did not verify any motel for this guide, so we do not name one.
Things to Do Near Your East Hampton Hotel
Several sights sit in the village. Expedia lists East Hampton Main Beach, Georgica Beach, Egypt Beach, Old Hook Mill, Guild Hall and the East Hampton Village Nature Trail and Wildlife Sanctuary.
Guild Hall hosts shows and exhibits. Check its calendar before your trip. Old Hook Mill is a historic windmill. Main Beach is the village beach. Beach parking rules and permits change, so ask your hotel about current rules.
Main Street shopping and dining sit close to The Maidstone, Mill House Inn and The Baker House 1650. Hotel guides name shops such as Veronica Beard and Citarella Gourmet Market along Main Street. We did not measure any walking distance, so ask your hotel.
Getting to East Hampton Without a Car
East Hampton has a Long Island Rail Road station on Railroad Avenue. The station sits on the Montauk Branch. Wikipedia notes limited service, plus a summer-only Cannonball train toward Montauk. Check the MTA schedule before you plan a car-free trip.
Suffolk County Transit route 92 serves the station. Parking is available along Railroad Avenue. Ask your hotel about taxis and ride services. Hotels such as The Maidstone and The Roundtree also list bikes for guests.
Closed or Changed: Old Listings to Skip
The Inn at East Hampton no longer operates under the old name. Journey East Hampton took over the site in 2018. If a travel site lists the old name, book through the new one.
Old listings of other kinds may still appear online. Always call before you book a property you cannot match to a current website and phone number.
How to Choose a Hotel in East Hampton
Pick a village inn if you want to walk to Main Street. The Maidstone, Mill House Inn and The Baker House 1650 all sit on Main Street or North Main Street.
Pick Journey East Hampton if you want a pool and a larger hotel layout. The hotel has no restaurant, so plan your dinners ahead.
Pick The Roundtree if you want a quiet stay in Amagansett. Pick Mill House Inn if you want a cooked breakfast included. Pick The Baker House 1650 if you want spa treatments on site.
Travelers with pets should call first. The Maidstone, Mill House Inn and The Roundtree list pet-friendly stays, but fees and room limits apply. Travelers with mobility needs should ask about accessible rooms at each property.
What We Checked and What We Could Not
We checked each East Hampton hotel against at least two independent sources. These included travel listings, hotel guides, a local news report and the inn’s own website.
We could not confirm current rates, so we list none. We could not confirm check-in times for The Baker House 1650. We could not confirm the pool claim at The Baker House. We could not confirm the exact room count at Mill House Inn or The Maidstone.
Opening status comes from live listings and guides. A listing is not proof of availability on your dates. Call each hotel to confirm.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best hotels in East Hampton, NY?
We confirmed The Maidstone, Mill House Inn, The Baker House 1650 and Journey East Hampton. The Roundtree sits nearby in Amagansett. Compare them by location, breakfast, pool access and pet rules.
Is there a motel in East Hampton, NY?
We found no motel inside East Hampton village. The confirmed properties are boutique inns and small hotels. Use the Expedia link on this page to check current options in nearby towns.
Which East Hampton hotel has a pool?
Journey East Hampton lists a heated saltwater pool. Mill House Inn and The Maidstone list none. A guest review mentions pools at The Baker House 1650, but the inn did not confirm this. Call to check.
Where can I stay in East Hampton near the beach?
The Maidstone offers bikes, and one guide puts East Hampton Beach about five minutes away by bike. Mill House Inn is not on the beach. Ask each hotel about beach access and parking rules.
Are East Hampton hotels pet friendly?
The Maidstone, Mill House Inn and The Roundtree list pet-friendly stays. Some Mill House Inn rooms do not allow pets. Fees and limits apply, so call before you travel.
Can I reach East Hampton without a car?
Yes, in part. The Long Island Rail Road serves East Hampton station on the Montauk Branch. Service is limited, so check the MTA schedule. Suffolk County Transit route 92 also serves the station.
Is Journey East Hampton the same as the Inn at East Hampton?
Yes. 27 East reported the sale of the Inn at East Hampton in 2018. The buyer rebranded the site as Journey East Hampton.
Conclusion
East Hampton offers a short list of boutique hotels and inns. The Maidstone, Mill House Inn, The Baker House 1650 and Journey East Hampton are our confirmed picks. The Roundtree is a quiet option in nearby Amagansett. Call ahead, confirm policies and check-in times, and book early for summer. Use the Expedia link at the top to compare current availability.