New Milford Hotels: Where to Stay in New Jersey
Hotels in New Milford, NJ are hard to find. See the verified Paramus hotels nearby, the old listings we removed, and what to do. Read before you book.
Searching for hotels in New Milford, NJ turns up a surprise. We could not confirm a single hotel or motel with a New Milford address. This guide tells you where to stay in New Milford, New Jersey in practice, which means the nearby Paramus hotels on Route 17. This guide also lists the old names we removed and the real sights worth a visit. We do not quote rates, because rates change every day.
Compare New Milford, New Jersey hotels on Expedia
Compare places to stay in New Milford, New Jersey
Live prices and availability on Expedia, for the dates you choose.
Check hotel prices →Booking is handled by Expedia. We may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you.
Where to Stay in New Milford, NJ
Table of Contents
Why There Is No Hotel in New Milford, NJ
New Milford is a small residential borough in Bergen County. The borough covers about 2.32 square miles and counted 16,923 residents in the 2020 census. Homes, schools and small shops fill the streets. We searched booking sites, hotel directories and local listings for a hotel or motel with a New Milford, NJ address. We found none we could confirm.
One hotel directory with a New Milford map shows no lodging inside the borough at all. Every hotel on its map sits in a nearby town. Several booking pages also mix New Milford, New Jersey with other places named New Milford, so a listing under the name may belong to another state. Check the full address before you pay for a room.
This matters because many older travel pages list hotels near the town and still call them New Milford hotels. Some of those pages name places in West Milford, which is a different town in Passaic County, far from the Hackensack River. We cut every one of those from this guide.
Hotels in New Milford, NJ: The Closest Places to Stay
The nearest full-service hotels sit just across the border in Paramus. They line Route 17, which is the main commercial road in the area. A hotel directory lists all three hotels below at 2.7 to 2.8 miles from New Milford. We could not confirm the exact starting point of the measure, so treat the figure as a rough guide and check your own route.
Each hotel below has at least two independent sources behind its details. Times and policies can change, so call before you book.
Best Western Paramus Hotel and Suites
This hotel stands at 211 Route 17 in Paramus, NJ 07652. Two listings describe a small property of 76 rooms over two floors with interior corridors. The property is smoke free.
One listing gives check-in as starting at 4:00 PM and check-out as 11:00 AM. A second listing did not show times, so confirm them with the front desk. Guests need a card or a cash deposit for extra charges and may need a photo ID.
Listed amenities include free parking, Wi-Fi, a fitness center, business services, a restaurant and bar, and a free breakfast. Some suites have jetted tubs. The hotel does not allow pets. Up to two children aged 18 and under can stay free in a parent or guardian room using existing bedding, and cots are not available.
This is the smallest of the three hotels. Pick this hotel if you want a quiet two-story property near Route 17 shops.
Courtyard by Marriott Paramus
The Courtyard stands at 320 Route 17 North, Paramus, NJ 07652. The phone number is 201-599-1414. Marriott lists check-in at 3:00 PM and check-out at 12:00 PM. The minimum check-in age is 21, and the property is smoke free.
Marriott lists two on-site food options. The Bistro serves breakfast and evening American dishes. The Market sells food and drinks around the clock. The hotel also has a 24-hour fitness center with a Peloton bike, self parking, electric vehicle charging subject to availability, laundry, meeting space and a business center.
Marriott says pets are welcome, with up to two per room and a 50 pound limit for each pet. A second site lists an indoor pool, but guest reviews on the same site say the pool was closed at times. Marriott does not list a pool on its own page. Call before you count on a swim.
This is the best fit for business travelers and for guests who bring a dog.
Comfort Inn Paramus Hackensack
This hotel stands at 50 Route 17 North, Paramus, NJ 07652. Some booking pages still show the old Holiday Inn Express name in their web addresses, so the property appears to have changed brands. Search for Comfort Inn when you book, and confirm the current brand by phone.
A hotel listing shows 89 rooms over two floors. Check-in starts at 3:00 PM and check-out is at 11:00 AM. The minimum check-in age is 21.
Listed amenities include a free buffet breakfast from 6:30 AM to 10:00 AM, free Wi-Fi, free self parking, electric vehicle charging, a fitness center and laundry. Pets are not allowed, though service animals are welcome. Children stay free when they use existing bedding in a parent or guardian room.
This is a practical pick for guests who want breakfast included and easy parking.
Motels Near New Milford, NJ
We did not find a motel with a verifiable New Milford address. Travel sites do show motel listings under the New Milford name. Most of those listings are in other towns and other states. The Travelocity motel page for New Milford, for example, lists properties in New York City suburbs, Elizabeth, North Bergen and Parsippany. None of them are near the borough.
If you want a budget room, use the three Paramus hotels as a baseline and compare other Bergen County towns on a booking site. Ask about taxes, parking and resort fees by phone before you commit. We do not quote any room rate in this guide because rates change daily.
Old Hotel Names We Removed From This Guide
An earlier version of this page listed ten places. We checked each one and could not confirm any as a lodging in New Milford, NJ. Here is what we found.
Several names used West Milford in the title, which is a separate town. We found no confirmed listing for an Inn at West Milford, a New Milford House dating to 1766, a Minerals Hotel and Suites, a Manor House, an Artful Dodger boutique hotel, or an Abbey Inn and Spa on Lake Hopatcong in the borough. We dropped them all.
Two other names belong to real places in other towns. Campgaw Mountain Reservation is a county park mostly in Mahwah, with parts in Oakland and Franklin Lakes. The park offers skiing and tubing, and has a day lodge but no overnight rooms we could confirm. Crystal Springs is a resort in northern New Jersey, not in New Milford, and we did not verify any room details there.
The old text also named Appalachian Trail campgrounds and a Greenwood Lake resort. Neither one sits in this borough. If you plan to camp or stay at a lake resort, search for the exact property and read its own address first.
Things to Do Near Hotels in New Milford, NJ
A stay in Paramus puts you a short drive from several real sights in and around New Milford. We list only places we could confirm.
New Bridge Landing is a New Jersey historic site shared by New Milford, River Edge and Teaneck. Local history says George Washington led his troops in retreat across the Hackensack River here during the Revolutionary War. The borough calls itself the Birthplace of Bergen County. The Steuben House is part of the site, and a state park page lists visiting details, but the page did not load for us. Check hours with the site before you go.
The Art Center of Northern New Jersey is in New Milford. A reference page says the center runs year-round art classes for adults and children. The center offers studios for painting, photography, printmaking and stone sculpture. The center also runs the Marcella Geltman Gallery, which hosts juried exhibits. We did not find a street address on the page we read, so look up current hours and the address on the center website.
The Hackensack River runs through the borough. The river rose to 11.84 feet in 2011 during Hurricane Irene, the second-highest crest on record. Check flood warnings in storm season when you plan a riverside walk.
Where to Stay in New Milford: How to Choose
Start with your plans. Business travelers who need meeting space and a late check-out will like the Courtyard, which lists a noon check-out. Families who want a free breakfast should look at the Comfort Inn and the Best Western. Guests who travel with a dog should pick the Courtyard, since the other two do not allow pets.
Next, check how you will get around. Route 17 is busy, and a car makes every stop easier. If you plan to go into Manhattan, NJ Transit bus route 167 runs from New Milford to the Port Authority Bus Terminal. The Pascack Valley Line serves the borough through the River Edge and New Bridge Landing stations, which sit across the river in River Edge. The line runs to Hoboken Terminal and connects to Penn Station through Secaucus Junction. Confirm schedules with NJ Transit before you travel.
Last, read the full address on any booking page. If the address says Paramus, you are staying in Paramus. This is fine, but you should know where you are headed.
Getting Around New Milford, NJ
Main roads in the borough include River Road, Madison Avenue, Milford Avenue, Henley Avenue and Boulevard. The borough hall stands at 930 River Road and the phone number is 201-967-5044. Call the borough for local questions about parking rules, events and road work.
Local bus routes 753, 756, 762 and 772 also serve the borough, according to a reference page. Rockland Coaches Route 21 to Midtown Manhattan has been inactive since the pandemic began.
What We Checked and What We Could Not Confirm
We checked every hotel name from the older page and found no confirmed hotel in New Milford, NJ. We checked three Paramus hotels against at least two sources each, including Marriott for the Courtyard and hotel listings for the others.
We could not confirm phone numbers for the Best Western and the Comfort Inn. We could not confirm the exact brand history of the Comfort Inn, the pool at the Courtyard, or the current hours at New Bridge Landing and the Art Center. We also could not confirm the exact starting point for the mile figures. We state no prices, because no price we saw could be verified as current.
Facts about the borough come mainly from one reference page and the borough website, so treat history and transport details as a guide and verify them before you travel.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are there hotels in New Milford, NJ?
We found no hotel with a confirmed New Milford address. The closest options are in Paramus, about 2.7 to 2.8 miles away according to one directory.
Where should I stay when visiting New Milford, NJ?
Choose a Paramus hotel on Route 17, such as the Best Western, the Courtyard by Marriott or the Comfort Inn. Confirm times and policies by phone.
Is the Inn at West Milford in New Milford?
No. West Milford is a different town in another county. We removed those listings from this guide.
Are there motels in New Milford, NJ?
We found no motel we could verify in the borough. Many motel listings under the New Milford name belong to other towns.
Can I bring a pet to a hotel near New Milford?
Marriott lists the Courtyard Paramus as pet friendly, with up to two pets per room and a 50 pound limit. The Best Western and Comfort Inn listings say no pets.
How do I get from New Milford to New York City?
NJ Transit bus route 167 runs to the Port Authority Bus Terminal. The Pascack Valley Line runs to Hoboken Terminal from stations across the river in River Edge. Check current schedules.
Conclusion
The honest answer on hotels in New Milford, NJ is short. The borough has no confirmed lodging, and the best places to stay sit nearby in Paramus. Pick the Courtyard for pets and business trips, the Comfort Inn for breakfast, or the Best Western for a small property. Call ahead, confirm the address and policies, and book early.