Elmira Hotels: Where to Stay in New York
It might not be the first place that springs to mind for a getaway, often bypassed for flashier destinations.
Elmira’s hotel market has a shape worth knowing before you book: the reliable chains sit in Horseheads and Big Flats along I-86, not in downtown Elmira itself. Rates run modest across the corridor, and the budget floor drops to $59 at the Mark Twain Motor Inn.
Compare Elmira, New York hotels on Expedia
Compare places to stay in Elmira, New York
Live prices and availability on Expedia, for the dates you choose.
Check hotel prices →Booking is handled by Expedia. We may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you.
A correction before the list. Earlier versions of this page described a restored 1920s “Mark Twain” hotel, a riverfront “Hotel Clemens” with a rooftop infinity pool, and a “Rathbone Mansion.” None of those operate as hotels today, and we could not verify two of them ever did in the form described. Everything below is bookable now.
| Hotel | Area | Best for |
|---|---|---|
| Holiday Inn Elmira-Horseheads | Horseheads | The full-service pick in Mark Twain Country |
| Hampton Inn Elmira/Horseheads | Horseheads | Families, free hot breakfast |
| Fairfield Inn & Suites Elmira Corning | Horseheads | Reliable rooms, indoor pool |
| Candlewood Suites Elmira Horseheads | Horseheads | Extended stays, full kitchens |
| Country Inn & Suites Big Flats | Big Flats | Families headed to Corning |
| Comfort Inn Horseheads | Horseheads | Budget with breakfast |
| Mark Twain Motor Inn | Elmira, Lake Street | The $59 floor, basics only |
How to pick along the corridor
The Holiday Inn Elmira-Horseheads carries the full-service load: restaurant, pool, and the event bookings. Hampton and Fairfield split the standard family trade with breakfast and indoor pools, and Candlewood takes anyone staying a week with kitchens and laundry in the room. Country Inn & Suites in Big Flats sits closest to the airport and the Corning side, which matters because the Corning Museum of Glass is the region’s anchor attraction, 20 minutes west.
At the bottom of the market, Comfort Inn Horseheads keeps breakfast in the deal, and the Mark Twain Motor Inn on Lake Street holds the true budget floor from $59, a plain motel trading on price and the borrowed name. Cross-check the whole field on Travel Weekly’s Elmira list.
Why Elmira, and when it fills
Mark Twain is the genuine draw, not a hotel theme. His actual study sits on the Elmira College campus and his grave is in Woodlawn Cemetery, both open to visitors. The Clemens Center stages touring shows downtown, the National Soaring Museum rides the ridge at Harris Hill with glider flights in season, and Eldridge Park spins a restored carousel on summer nights.
Demand peaks on Corning-driven weekends, Elmira College events, and soaring season at Harris Hill. Watkins Glen race weekends, 40 minutes north, drain rooms across the whole region, and those dates deserve the earliest booking of all.
FAQs
What is the best hotel in Elmira, New York?
The Holiday Inn Elmira-Horseheads for full service, the Hampton Inn for families. Both sit minutes from downtown Elmira on the I-86 corridor.
Is there a hotel in downtown Elmira itself?
Not a chain property. The Mark Twain Motor Inn on Lake Street is the closest budget option, and the Horseheads cluster is a 10-minute drive from the Clemens Center.
What fills Elmira hotels?
Corning Museum of Glass tourism, Elmira College weekends, Harris Hill soaring season, and Watkins Glen race dates. Any of those on your calendar means booking early.