Mineola Hotels: Where to Stay in New York
Mineola hotels sit in Garden City, Carle Place, and Westbury. See which properties we confirmed, what we could not, and how to pick the right base.
Mineola is the county seat of Nassau County on Long Island, and Mineola hotels are harder to find than you might expect. In the listings we reviewed, we found no full-service hotel inside the village. Nearly every property sold as a Mineola hotel sits in Garden City, Carle Place, or Westbury. This guide covers the hotels in Mineola NY we could confirm, names the town each one really sits in, and flags every detail we could not verify. We left out rates, because they change daily. Call each property before you pay.
Compare Mineola, New York hotels on Expedia
Compare places to stay in Mineola, New York
Live prices and availability on Expedia, for the dates you choose.
Check hotel prices →Booking is handled by Expedia. We may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you.
Hotels in Mineola NY: What We Found
Table of Contents
The Garden City Hotel
The Garden City Hotel is the best-known address near Mineola. The hotel stands at 45 7th Street in Garden City, according to a travel listing. Wikipedia says the current building opened on 20 May 1983 and has 269 guest rooms, 16 suites, and five restaurants. The hotel site lists 269 rooms and suites and a dining program led by chef David Burke, including Red Salt Room by David Burke. The site also lists a Sunday brunch, room service, and event space for weddings and meetings.
An older version of this guide called the hotel a 1927 landmark on the National Register of Historic Places with a restaurant named The Polo Steakhouse. We could not confirm either claim, so we removed both. The history is real, but the story differs. A hotel opened on the site in 1874 under the merchant Alexander Turney Stewart. McKim, Mead and White designed two later buildings. The 1895 building burned down in 1899. The 1901 building closed in 1972 and came down in 1973. The hotel you can book today dates from 1983.
We could not confirm check-in times, pet rules, or parking terms from the hotel site. Ask about all three when you call. Pick this hotel if you want a large full-service property with on-site restaurants and event space.
Hampton Inn Garden City Long Island
Hampton Inn stands at 1 North Avenue in Garden City. Two booking sources list a free breakfast and a fitness center. Both list an indoor pool as well. One source adds a hot tub, laundry, a business center, a meeting room, an elevator, and a bar. The same source says pets are allowed with a fee, so confirm the fee and the weight limits before you bring a dog.
A booking source places the hotel next to Roosevelt Field Mall. Another describes room layouts with two queen beds and a sofa sleeper, which suits a family of five. We could not confirm check-in and check-out times. Pick this hotel if you want a pool, a free breakfast, and a family room.
Hyatt Place Garden City
Hyatt Place stands at 5 North Avenue in Garden City. The operator, OTO Development, lists 122 rooms across six floors. A second travel listing agrees on the room count and the six floors. The operator says the hotel sits within walking distance of the Garden City train station on the Long Island Rail Road.
The operator lists a free hot breakfast, a fitness center, 1,149 square feet of meeting space, and The Placery restaurant. The same page says pets are welcome. A travel-trade listing shows check-in at 3:00 PM and check-out at 12:00 PM, a 2009 opening, and a 2016 renovation. We treat the times as unconfirmed. Pick this hotel if you plan to ride the train and want a simple modern room.
Residence Inn Long Island Garden City
Residence Inn opened on 20 May 2020 at Roosevelt Field, according to a trade press release. The release counts 163 studio and one-bedroom suites, each with a full kitchen. The address is 700 Garden City Plaza in Garden City, and a second listing gives the same address. The release also lists free Wi-Fi, an indoor pool, a putting green, a fitness center, laundry service, and a 500-square-foot meeting room.
The release calls the hotel the first to open in Garden City since 1983. Pick this hotel for a stay of several nights. A kitchen helps anyone who wants to cook, and the suites give a family more space than a standard room.
La Quinta Inn and Suites by Wyndham Garden City
La Quinta stands at 821 Stewart Avenue in Garden City, according to two travel listings. One listing shows a free breakfast, free parking, three meeting rooms, and a pet-friendly policy. We found no second source for those details, so we mark them unconfirmed. Call the hotel to confirm the pet rules and the parking terms before you book.
Hotels Near Mineola in Carle Place and Westbury
Several chain hotels sit a short drive from Mineola in Carle Place and Westbury. Two travel sites list each of the properties below. We did not measure drive times, so check a map for your route.
SpringHill Suites by Marriott Carle Place Garden City
SpringHill Suites stands at 20 Westbury Avenue in Carle Place. One listing counts 120 rooms. Two sources list an indoor pool, a fitness center, and a free breakfast. The sources disagree on parking. One says parking is free and the other says a parking fee applies. Ask the front desk for the current policy.
Pick this hotel if you want a pool and a breakfast buffet. The room design includes a sofa bed and a work desk, according to one listing.
Homewood Suites by Hilton Carle Place Garden City
Homewood Suites stands at 40 Westbury Avenue in Carle Place. Two sources list a free breakfast and a kitchen in each suite. One listing describes a kitchenette with a stove, a microwave, and a full-size refrigerator. The same listing adds an indoor pool, a fitness center, a business center, and electric vehicle charging.
The listing also mentions a parking fee. Confirm the fee when you book. Pick this hotel if you want a kitchen and a hot breakfast without a long stay.
Westbury Hotels Within Reach of Mineola
Westbury has a cluster of business hotels. The Hilton Garden Inn Westbury stands at 1575 Privado Road and one listing counts 140 rooms. The Courtyard Westbury Long Island stands at 1800 Privado Road. The Holiday Inn Westbury stands at 369 Old Country Road in Carle Place. The Red Roof Inn PLUS+ Long Island Garden City stands at 699 Dibblee Drive in Westbury, and one listing counts 163 rooms and lists a pet-friendly policy.
Two other Westbury names appear in our sources. The Vanderbilt stands at 990 Corporate Drive, and a listing shows a restaurant and five conference rooms. Viana Hotel and Spa stands at 3998 Brush Hollow Road, and a listing counts eight suites. An older version of this guide described Viana as a restored 19th-century mansion and The Vanderbilt as an art hotel with a gallery. We could not confirm either claim, so we removed both.
We could not confirm amenities, policies, or check-in times for these Westbury hotels. Treat the addresses as the confirmed part and phone each front desk for the rest.
Motels Near Mineola
Mineola has no motel row we could confirm, but Jericho Turnpike runs through the village and a few motels sit along the same road in nearby towns. A listing shows Meadowbrook Motor Lodge at 440 Jericho Turnpike in Jericho with 75 rooms and a free breakfast. The same listing shows The Floral Park Motor Lodge at 30 Jericho Turnpike in Floral Park and the Paramount Inn at 256-15 Jericho Turnpike in Floral Park.
We found one source for each motel. We could not confirm current operation, ownership, or amenities, so we do not recommend any of them without a call. Motel listings often carry stale details. Search the address on a booking site, read the current name, and phone the front desk before you plan around a motel.
Where to Stay Near Mineola Attractions
Mineola itself is a county seat with a compact downtown. Governor Theodore Roosevelt laid the cornerstone of the Nassau County Court House in 1900, according to Wikipedia. The village also has a Portuguese community of about 1,900 residents and a Portuguese business scene. Aviation pioneers including the Wright Brothers and Igor Sikorsky worked in the area, and Charles Lindbergh took off for his 1927 flight from nearby Roosevelt Field.
Two family attractions sit near the Garden City hotels in the East Garden City part of Uniondale. The Long Island Children’s Museum stands at 11 Davis Avenue on the former Mitchel Field campus. Wikipedia lists 12 galleries and three studio workshops. The Cradle of Aviation Museum sits on the former Mitchel Air Force Base and holds more than 70 aircraft and scale models. The collection includes a Lunar Module and Charles Lindbergh’s Curtiss Jenny. We did not confirm opening hours, so check each museum site before you go.
Roosevelt Field Mall sits beside the Residence Inn and the Hampton Inn, according to the hotel sources above. Families and shoppers can stay in Garden City and skip a second drive.
Getting to Mineola and Getting Around
The Mineola station serves the Long Island Rail Road Main Line, and the Mineola Intermodal Center also hosts Nassau Inter-County Express buses. Wikivoyage says trips to Penn Station or Grand Central take under 40 minutes. Check the Metropolitan Transportation Authority site for current schedules.
By car, Wikivoyage says to use Exit 31A from the Northern State Parkway or Exit 39 from the Long Island Expressway. Route 25, known as Jericho Turnpike, crosses the village from east to west. Wikivoyage calls the area around the station walkable, and calls the whole village very walkable. People generally drive across Long Island, so a Garden City or Carle Place hotel works best if you have a car.
Garden City has five Long Island Rail Road stations, according to Wikipedia, and the Hyatt Place operator says the hotel sits within walking distance of the Garden City station. Visitors without a car should favor Hyatt Place for this reason.
How to Choose Among Mineola Hotels
Families do well at Hampton Inn and SpringHill Suites. Both list a pool and a free breakfast, and Hampton Inn lists a room with two queen beds and a sofa sleeper.
Longer stays point to Residence Inn and Homewood Suites. Both list kitchens in every suite.
Travelers who want a landmark hotel with restaurants should look at The Garden City Hotel. Ask about pets, parking, and check-in before you book.
Train commuters should look at Hyatt Place, which sits within walking distance of a Long Island Rail Road station according to its operator.
Pet owners should call before booking. Sources say Hampton Inn and Hyatt Place accept pets, and one listing marks La Quinta and Red Roof Inn as pet friendly. Fees and size limits differ and we could not confirm any of them.
Budget travelers should compare the total with taxes and fees on two booking sites and by phone. Parking fees appear on some listings and not on others, so ask for the full amount before you pay.
Before you pay, confirm the town name in the address, the cancellation policy, parking terms, breakfast hours, and late arrival rules.
What We Checked and What We Could Not
We checked Garden City Hotel history against Wikipedia and the hotel site. We took Hyatt Place facts from its operator and a travel-trade listing. We took Residence Inn facts from a trade press release. We took Hampton Inn, SpringHill Suites, and Homewood Suites amenities from booking sources and a hotel listing site. We took Mineola and Garden City background from Wikipedia and Wikivoyage. We took museum details from Wikipedia.
We could not confirm current rates, check-in times for most properties, the Westbury hotel amenities, or the motel status. We found no hotel inside Mineola village limits in the listings we read, but a small lodging could exist and escape the listings. We print no phone numbers because we could not confirm current ones. Confirm each detail with the property before you travel.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are there hotels in Mineola, NY?
We found no full-service hotel inside Mineola village in the listings we reviewed. Most Mineola hotels sit in Garden City, Carle Place, and Westbury. Check the town in the address before you book.
What is the best hotel near Mineola?
The Garden City Hotel is the best-known, with 269 rooms and a dining program led by chef David Burke. Hampton Inn and SpringHill Suites suit families. Residence Inn and Homewood Suites offer kitchens.
Are there cheap hotels or motels in Mineola?
We could not confirm any motel inside Mineola. A listing shows motels on Jericho Turnpike in Jericho and Floral Park. We found one source for each, so call before you plan around them. We do not quote rates.
Can I reach Mineola from New York City by train?
Yes. Mineola sits on the Long Island Rail Road Main Line. Wikivoyage says trips from Penn Station or Grand Central take under 40 minutes. Check the Metropolitan Transportation Authority for current schedules.
Which Mineola area hotels accept pets?
Sources say Hampton Inn and Hyatt Place accept pets. A listing marks La Quinta and Red Roof Inn as pet friendly. Call each hotel for the current fee and size limits.
Where should I stay for the Long Island Children’s Museum?
Garden City hotels such as Hampton Inn, Residence Inn, and Hyatt Place sit in the same area as the museum on Davis Avenue. Check a map for your route and the museum site for hours.
Conclusion
Mineola hotels are mostly a short trip away in Garden City, Carle Place, and Westbury. The Garden City Hotel offers the most amenities. Hampton Inn and SpringHill Suites suit families. Residence Inn and Homewood Suites suit longer stays. Hyatt Place suits train travelers. Call ahead, confirm the town and the current policies, and book early for your trip to Mineola.