Sag Harbor Hotels: Where to Stay in New York
Best hotels in Sag Harbor, New York: Faraway (ex Baron's Cove), Sag Harbor Inn and The American Hotel. Addresses, pet rules and unconfirmed details.
Sag Harbor is a small village on the East End of Long Island, and the lodging list is short. Three hotels sit inside the village. A fourth and fifth sit in neighboring Hamptons communities. This guide covers the best hotels in Sag Harbor, New York we could confirm, plus the changes you should know about. Baron’s Cove now operates as Faraway Sag Harbor. Several places named in older guides could not be verified, so we dropped them. Rates change daily, so we do not quote any. Cheap hotels in Sag Harbor are hard to find in this village, and we explain how to compare your options.
Compare Sag Harbor, New York hotels on Expedia
Compare places to stay in Sag Harbor, New York
Live prices and availability on Expedia, for the dates you choose.
Check hotel prices →Booking is handled by Expedia. We may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you.
Best Hotels in Sag Harbor, New York
Table of Contents
Faraway Sag Harbor, Formerly Baron’s Cove
Faraway Sag Harbor is the largest hotel in the village. The address is 31 West Water Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963. Older guides list the phone as 844-227-6672. Because the brand changed, confirm the current number with the hotel before you call.
The property was Baron’s Cove for years. Hotels Above Par reports the hotel reopened as Faraway Sag Harbor in June 2025 after a seven-month renovation. Other sources describe a 2026 opening and a renovation across 2025 and 2026. Sources disagree on the timing, so ask the hotel which rooms and services are running on your dates.
The hotel has 67 rooms and suites. Michelin Guide lists lofts and garden rooms. One source describes Village rooms with garden access and Harbor rooms with water views. Some lofts and suites sleep up to five guests.
Amenities include a heated outdoor pool, a padel court, a fitness room, complimentary bicycles, and complimentary parking. Hotels Above Par also lists beach chairs and towels for guests who walk to Havens Beach. Michelin Guide lists a 24-hour front desk, EV charging, a bar, and wheelchair access. Two sources list dog-friendly rooms. Call to ask about pet fees and weight limits.
The on-site restaurant is Zagara, which serves Amalfi-inspired coastal dishes. One source lists dinner hours of 5 to 10 PM Tuesday through Saturday, 5 to 9 PM on Sunday, and closed Mondays. We found only one source for those hours, so confirm them before you plan a dinner.
We could not find check-in and check-out times in our sources. Ask when you book.
Pick Faraway if you want a pool, a restaurant on site, and the most room choices in the village.
Sag Harbor Inn near Main Street
Sag Harbor Inn stands at 45 West Water Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963. The inn lists its phone as 631-725-2949. The inn site shows the message WE ARE OPEN. One directory shows a different street number, 4 West Water Street. Three other sources agree on 45, so we use 45.
A major booking site lists check-in from 3:00 PM and check-out before 11:00 AM. Guests must be at least 21 to check in, according to the same listing. The listing also shows a free continental breakfast from 7:00 to 10:30 AM, free Wi-Fi, free parking, a 24-hour front desk, a lobby fireplace, and a meeting room.
The outdoor pool runs seasonally. The booking listing gives May through October, with pool hours from 10:00 AM to 7:00 PM. The listing says pets are not allowed, though service animals are welcome. If you travel with a dog, look at Faraway instead.
Room counts differ. Seen by Amy describes 42 suites with private balconies or terraces. The booking listing shows 11 room types. The two figures can both be true, because one counts rooms and the other counts categories. Ask the front desk how many rooms fit your group.
The inn sits a short walk from Main Street, according to The Long Island Local. We did not find a sourced walking time, so check a map.
Pick Sag Harbor Inn if you want breakfast included, free parking, and a base close to the shops. Guests who want cheap hotels in Sag Harbor should compare this inn on two booking sites and by phone.
The American Hotel on Main Street
The American Hotel stands at 49 Main Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963. Call 631-725-3535. One directory lists 25 Main Street, but three sources use 49, so we use 49.
The hotel has eight guest rooms. The East Hampton tourism site and Dan’s Papers describe the rooms as furnished with antiques. Dan’s Papers reports the rooms have no televisions, which suits guests who want quiet. Seen by Amy lists en suite bathrooms with whirlpool tubs, sitting areas, air conditioning, and Wi-Fi. A 27east writer praises Victorian and Gothic Revival antiques and L’Occitane bath products.
The building has a long history. The Long Island Local dates the hotel to 1846. Dan’s Papers traces the site to the James Howell Inn, a brick rebuild in 1824, and hotel use from 1876. Ted Conklin bought the property in 1972 and restored the building. The sources do not agree on one founding date, so we report both.
The restaurant is the main draw. Dan’s Papers reports Wine Spectator has given the restaurant its Grand Award every year since 1981. The wine list holds about 2,500 selections.
The hotel site says the hotel sits a three-minute walk from the harbor and a six-minute walk from the Sag Harbor Whaling Museum.
We could not confirm check-in times, parking, or pet rules. Call before you book.
Pick The American Hotel if you want a historic room above the main street and a serious dinner downstairs. The small room count means you should reserve early.
Hotels Near Sag Harbor in East Hampton and Bridgehampton
The earlier version of this guide mixed hotels from neighboring villages into the Sag Harbor list. Both places are real. Neither one sits in Sag Harbor.
The Maidstone is a hotel at 207 Main Street in East Hampton. Dan’s Papers reported a 2023 sale to Irwin D. Simon and hotelier Mayank Dwivedi. The article describes 19 guest rooms, including several cottages, and a 76-seat restaurant. The hotel has operated since about 1840. Owners and policies may have changed since 2023, so call 631-324-5006 or check the hotel site before you plan.
Topping Rose House is a hotel in Bridgehampton. An Expedia listing shows the hotel as open, with check-in from 3:00 PM, check-out at noon, a spa, a restaurant, a seasonal pool, and free bicycles. The listing shows the pool closed from September 15 to May 24. We did not confirm the distance to Sag Harbor, so check a map.
Both hotels work as backups when Sag Harbor rooms sell out.
Old Listings We Dropped
The earlier version of this guide named Harbor Watch Inn. We searched for the name and found no lodging under the name in Sag Harbor. We removed the entry.
The old guide also listed Sunset Beach as a Sag Harbor stay. We could not verify a Sag Harbor property with the name, so we left the entry out.
Older web guides also list Forever Bungalows on Route 114. The website for the name now shows unrelated content, so we could not confirm the property is open. We did not include the bungalows.
The Watchcase is a converted factory building in the village. Sources describe the building as condominiums with some short-term rentals. We do not count the building as a hotel.
Where to Stay in Sag Harbor by Traveler Type
Couples who want a quiet room and a great dinner should call The American Hotel first. The rooms have no televisions, and the restaurant sits downstairs.
Families and groups should look at Faraway Sag Harbor. The hotel has lofts and multi-bedroom suites for up to five guests, plus a pool and bicycles.
Dog owners should start with Faraway. Two sources list dog-friendly rooms. Sag Harbor Inn does not allow pets.
Guests who want breakfast and free parking should look at Sag Harbor Inn. The listing shows a free continental breakfast and free parking.
Anyone searching for cheap hotels in Sag Harbor should know the village has only three hotels. We did not find a budget chain or a roadside motel inside the village. Compare the total price with taxes and fees on two booking sites and by phone.
Travelers who miss out on a room can check East Hampton and Bridgehampton, or find vacation rentals. Rentals book far in advance in summer, according to Social Life Magazine.
What to Do Near Your Sag Harbor Hotel
The Sag Harbor Whaling and Historical Museum sits at 200 Main Street. Dan’s Papers describes the museum as holding more than 3,500 objects and the largest collection of whaling equipment in New York State. The listing shows an open season from mid-May to October, closed Mondays and Tuesdays. Call 631-725-0770 to confirm current hours.
Havens Beach is at 145 Bay Street. The beach is the only public beach in the village with bay views. The beach has restrooms, a playground, and a gazebo. Parking passes are required. Foster Memorial Beach also offers calm bay swimming, according to Long Island Press.
Bay Street Theater sits at 1 Long Wharf. The theater produces music, comedy, and plays year round. Call 631-725-9500 for the schedule. The restored Sag Harbor Cinema is an art deco theater with three screens.
John Steinbeck Waterfront Park offers about 1.25 acres of green space beside the water. The Elizabeth A. Morton Wildlife Refuge is at 2595 Noyac Road. The refuge protects a 187-acre peninsula and has a self-guided trail just over one mile long. The refuge is open from half an hour before sunrise to half an hour after sunset.
The Sag Harbor Variety Store has sold crafts and fabrics at 114 Main Street since 1922.
Getting to Sag Harbor
Sag Harbor sits on the East End of Long Island. Part of the village lies in Southampton and part in East Hampton, with Division Street marking the boundary. Wikipedia reports a 2020 population of 2,772.
The Hamptons Jitney and other transit options serve the area, according to Wikipedia. Hotels Above Par lists East Hampton Airport as a 25-minute trip and JFK as about 2.5 hours. Traffic changes both times, so check a map for your travel date.
What We Checked and What We Could Not
We checked Faraway Sag Harbor against Hotels Above Par, Michelin Guide, Deep Arrival, and Social Life Magazine. We checked Sag Harbor Inn against its own site, an Expedia listing, The Long Island Local, and Seen by Amy. We checked The American Hotel against Dan’s Papers, 27east, The Long Island Local, and its site. We took attraction details from Dan’s Papers, Long Island Press, and Wikipedia.
We could not confirm current rates, Faraway check-in times, American Hotel check-in times, or the current Faraway phone number. We could not reach the official Faraway site, so brand details come from the sources above. Sources disagree on the Faraway reopening date. Policies change, so confirm every detail with the property before you travel.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best hotels in Sag Harbor?
We confirmed three hotels in the village. Faraway Sag Harbor, formerly Baron’s Cove, has 67 rooms and a pool. Sag Harbor Inn offers continental breakfast and free parking. The American Hotel has eight antique-filled rooms and a noted restaurant.
Is Baron’s Cove still open?
Baron’s Cove now operates as Faraway Sag Harbor at 31 West Water Street. Sources disagree on whether the reopening came in 2025 or 2026. Call the hotel to confirm which services run on your dates.
Are there cheap hotels in Sag Harbor?
The village has only three hotels, and we found no budget chain or roadside motel inside the village. We do not quote rates. Compare the total price with taxes and fees on two booking sites and by phone.
Which Sag Harbor hotels allow dogs?
Two sources list dog-friendly rooms at Faraway Sag Harbor. A booking listing says Sag Harbor Inn does not allow pets, though service animals are welcome. Call Faraway to ask about pet fees and size limits.
Does Sag Harbor Inn include breakfast?
A booking listing shows a free continental breakfast daily from 7:00 to 10:30 AM. The listing also shows free parking and a seasonal pool open May through October. Call 631-725-2949 to confirm.
Is the Maidstone in Sag Harbor?
No. The Maidstone is at 207 Main Street in East Hampton. Topping Rose House is in Bridgehampton. Both serve as nearby backups when Sag Harbor rooms are full.
Conclusion
Sag Harbor has a short lodging list. Faraway Sag Harbor, Sag Harbor Inn, and The American Hotel give you three clear choices for the best hotels in Sag Harbor, New York. Faraway suits families and dog owners. Sag Harbor Inn suits guests who want breakfast and parking. The American Hotel suits couples who want history and a fine dinner. Call ahead, confirm the current policies, and book early for summer weekends.