Every airport gives you the same four choices in some form: a train, a taxi, a shared shuttle, or a car you drive or hire privately. The right answer is rarely about which is nicest. It is about how many of you there are, what time you land, and whether the airport publishes a fare you can hold anyone to.
Here is the decision as we make it, and what to check before you commit.
Take the train when there is one
A rail link is usually the only option with a journey time you can trust at 5pm on a Friday. At Atlanta the MARTA ride into Five Points is 18 to 19 minutes whatever the interstate is doing, for $2.50 against a $37.50 flat cab fare. At Heathrow the Elizabeth line does the same job for about a third of a black cab.
Two things break this rule. Heavy luggage and stairs, and a final destination that is nowhere near a station. A train that leaves you a twelve minute walk from your hotel at midnight has not saved you anything.
Take a taxi when the airport publishes the fare
This is the single most useful thing to check before you land. Some airports publish flat fares by zone, some publish nothing at all, and the difference changes how you should behave at the rank.
- Published: Atlanta posts $37.50 downtown, $39.50 Midtown, $49.50 Buckhead. London does not post a flat fare but Transport for London publishes an expected range of £70 to £120 into the centre, which is enough to argue with.
- Not published: Birmingham and Huntsville, Alabama both list permitted taxi companies and no fares whatsoever. Agree a basis before you set off, or phone ahead.
A cab also wins on simple arithmetic more often than people expect. Four people and a fixed fare usually beats four separate rail tickets plus a connection at the far end.
Take a shared shuttle when you are leaving the metro area
Shared vans are poor value inside a city and excellent value for the two hour hop nobody else covers. Atlanta to Birmingham, Auburn or Montgomery runs daily from the regional stalls at the Ground Transportation Centre for a fraction of a one-way car rental. The catch is that these fill up, so they are a booking, not a decision you make at the kerb.
Hire a car when the destination has no other route
Sometimes there is genuinely nothing else. No city bus serves Huntsville International, and nothing but a car reaches Redstone Arsenal or Cummings Research Park reliably. In that situation the question is not whether to rent but what time the counter shuts. Several Birmingham desks close at midnight, and Hertz, Dollar and Thrifty close at 10pm on Saturdays. A delayed flight and a closed counter is a bad combination at 1am.
If someone is collecting you
Free cell phone lots exist at most US airports and cost nothing: Birmingham’s is on Airline Drive with no time limit, Huntsville’s is under a minute from baggage claim, and Huntsville gives you the first 30 minutes free in any lot on top.
The UK works the other way. Heathrow bans forecourt pickups outright, charges £7 just to drop off, and sits inside the ULEZ, so an older car pays £12.50 on top. The free move there is the Park & Ride car park, which gives you 29 minutes at no charge.
The airports we have covered in detail
- Birmingham, Alabama (BHM) — rental counters in the deck, 24 hour cab rank, and the on-demand service that replaced the airport bus.
- Huntsville, Alabama (HSV) — no city bus at all, six hotels that run shuttles, and free short-stay parking.
- Atlanta (ATL) — MARTA, published taxi flat rates, the rideshare walk to the North Economy Lot, and shuttles into Alabama.
- London Heathrow (LHR) — six ways into town compared, and why Terminal 4 catches people out.
Fares and hours in those guides were checked in August 2026 against official airport and transit sources, and each guide says plainly where nothing official is published rather than filling the gap with an estimate.
Germ Trips earns a commission if you book through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. Bookings are handled by the travel company you are sent to, not by us. It never changes what we tell you about a ticket. How this works.